When I sat down to write this blog, I was reminded of my first blog about how Cindy and I first got together. Through 11 years of middle school, high school, and college, Cindy and I were never more than casual acquintances, and now we’re going to get married and have our own baby. When I first wrote that post, I mentioned that it was one part of a three part series, not really knowing what parts two and three would be. You can find that post here, and consider this blog, part two.
The date was April 26th, 2009. It was late evening, and I was driving home from Muncie, IN, where I had just watched my good friend Curtis Painter get drafted by the my favorite team, The Indianapolis Colts. The Painter house was filled with friends and family, and erupted in celebration when Curtis’ phone rang, and minutes later his name popped up on the screen. We all celebrated, cried, hugged, and attempted to maintain the same assemblance of calm that Curtis always shows in almost every situation. After an hour of celebrating, I knew we had a three hour drive home, school and work in the morning, and the kids needed to get to their mom’s house.
You would think this would be reason enough to FLOAT home on fluffy, white clouds, but the selection of my favorite Boilermaker was a distant second place to the real reason I had wings that day. —>Place RedBull Joke Here<—
For those paying attention, one might realize that the date mentioned above was a mere 9 days after the first night that Cindy and I had gone out together with friends. We had spent the entire following week talking on the phone, looking over calendars, and trying to find a way to see each other again. We both admitted that we didn’t know “what this was”, but it was worth finding out. On Saturday morning, the 25th, Avery and Carson both had a soccer game, and then we were scheduled to drive to Indianapolis, IN to stay with my friend Doug, and his wife Jana. The kids hadn’t seen Doug and Jana in a while, and we were all excited to get some quality time together. Cindy on the other hand was in beautiful Athens, OH for work. She had taken Xavier with her, and expected to stay there Saturday night.
Cindy called me that Saturday morning and said her conference was ending early, and perhaps we could meet up in Indianapolis. I called Doug, we discussed the options and figured it would be a great opportunity for the kids to meet Cindy, Xavier to meet me and the kids, Doug and Jana to meet Cindy, etc…all the while under a guise of “she’s just a friend”. It seemed very low key for all of us to come together and see what kind of energy we could create with the five of us all together. Was it risky? Sure. Was it dumb? Perhaps. Did it work? YES!!! We visited with each other the whole evening, it was the first time “The Hicks Family” as we know it today was together. (Thanks Doug and Jana) After the kids had gone to bed, Xavier fell asleep on the couch, the four adults sat outside and chatted up about days past. Doug and I smoked a few cigars, we drank a few beers, and I watched this beautiful girl’s smile in the flickering flame of a centranella candle. After Doug and Jana went to bed, Cindy and I grabbed a blanket and sat on the back deck and talked until almost three in the morning. We could have talked until three the next morning, but it was getting late, and I had to be at the Painter house the next day and Cindy needed to get Xavier home. I carried him to the car, loaded him in, gave Cindy a kiss goodbye and she drove away. I knew THEN. I wanted to marry her….THEN.
As I was driving home from the Painter’s on Sunday evening, I was texting with friends about my excitement for Curtis, and my even bigger joy of spending more time with this girl that lit my world on fire. In fact, I was texting with my good friend Kristen (not HFO Kristen), and I told her “I will bet you $50 that I’m going to marry Cindy within three years. She took the bet…not knowing what I knew in my heart at that time, I decided the previous night that this was it, Cindy was “it”.
The amount of material between THEN and now, is far too expansive for a blog, but we have memory after memory after memory after memory after memory…after memory…….after memory. I can’t even begin to tell you the overwhelming joy we’ve experienced raising our kids together, laughing hysterically, teaching each other things, listening, crying, loving, and most importantly building, building our life together. Jesus told us to build on a Rock and we’ll be wise builders. No matter what happens, if we build on that Rock, the rains, sleet, wind, and snow cannot tear down our house.
The actual topic of our marriage had weighed on me for a few months. I knew I wanted to by married to Cindy, but it was more complicated that I wanted to admit. I could feel God tapping me on the shoulder every so often to remind me of “the right thing to do”. There were alot of reasons why we had not taken that step forward, but none of them meant that I couldn’t make that first step to show everyone and most imporantly Cindy, my commitment to this family and to our future.
It wasn’t until our brief hospital stay two weeks ago that I really decided that I wanted to make this happen. Nothing is guaranteed in life, and any second could be our last, and I’ll be damned if I’m going to let one more second pass without showing Cindy the commitment that is in my heart to her and this family. I decided in that hospital room that I was going to take whatever risk, do whatever I could, and make whatever sacrifice to make my intention felt with her, and known in our circle. So I started the process of finding and securing a ring that made me feel was deserved enough of Cindy’s finger. Luckily, I have a great, great friend in the jewelry business who made the process easy for me and even had her eye on a certain ring that she felt “was Cindy”. She was right.
I sought out, pined over, paid for, picked up, and hid this ring for about two weeks all the while, Cindy knew nothing. The beautiful thing about trust in a relationship is it makes “good surprises” easy to achieve because the other isn’t constantly asking you questions. I was able to do all of this without Cindy even knowing.
I picked up the ring on Tuesday July 13th, and so started the journey to Cindy’s hand. This was right around the time I would find myself talking to myself in the mirror saying things like “She wants its”…”Let’s gives it to her”..”It’s her precious, she must haves it”…I could barely sleep the next few nights. I had horrible, horrible nightmares about losing the ring, getting the ring stolen, and screwing up the proposal. It was tucked into a special compartment in my backpack. In normal situations, I usually keep that backpack close to me because it has most of my personal belongings, laptop, wallet, etc…but now, it was talking to me. I would turn around and swear that the bag had moved across the room, and I would instantly panic…DID SHE KNOW!?? DID MY FRIENDS SAY SOMETHING?!!! WHERE IS THE RING!!?? My bag didn’t move, and the ring was safely tucked away. I wanted to get rid of this ring so badly, I had to stop myself from proposing in the dairy queen parking lot just so I could feel the relief that Frodo had when he threw the ring in the mountain. (There is no corrolation here between marrying Cindy and MOUNT DOOM!)
For our anniversary in April, I had given Cindy two tickets to see Brad Paisley and Darius Rucker (Hootie), two of our favorite country artists. This gift was a little sentimental because Brad Paisley sings “our song”. I know alot of people have “their songs”, but Cindy and I have an undisputable number one choice that trumps all others. Brad Paisley’s “Then” was on the radio shortly after we met, Cindy sent me a text that she loved that song and it made her think of me. The song stuck, and its been “our song” ever since.
My initial thought was to pop the question, DURING the song, at the concert. It would have been very sentimental for us, although in my eyes, just a tad cheesy. I toiled over this idea for a few weeks, but decided that proposing around a bunch of drunk, shirtless hillbillies wasn’t very romantic. Knowing how badly I wanted to give this ring to her, I thought it would be a good idea to keep it in the backpack until Saturday night. If I took it to the concert, I knew that I would either lose it or prematurely ask her to marry me. There is nothing worse than premature proposal. As it turned out, the concert was AMAZING, but I was glad I didn’t bring the ring. When Brad Paisley sang our song, it was very emotional and special, but the surrounding said drunk hillbillies made it an environment unconducive to proposing. However, the concert itself was extremely fun and exciting for both of us, and really set the weekend off on the right foot.
My ultimate plan was for the weekend was to ask Cindy to marry me at Navy Pier on Saturday evening. We were house sitting for a friend of mine in Wicker Park on the west side of downtown. Cindy thought it would be fun to grab a bit to eat and walk the Navy Pier midway and just enjoy the night. Little did she know, her idea played right into my hand.
Saturday afternoon, we visited Arlington Park Race Track. Cindy really enjoys horseracing from her long history of living in Louisville, so she was in heaven. The weather was perfect, the day was perfect, and we got to spend the afternoon hanging out with good friends, and we actually won some money. We had an amazing afternoon.
If you couple our afternoon at the track, with our amazing experience at the concert, this weekend was already scarily perfect, and only I knew that it was going to get better. I tried to contain my excitement and remain a little low key. Cindy said later, “at least I knew why you weren’t eating very much”. I was very nervous for this moment, because nothing is ever guaranteed and I wanted the moment to be right and the setting to be even more right.
We got down to Navy Pier a little later than I had hoped, but wasn’t too concerned about timing. My plan at that point was to find a place that was reasonably away from the crowd where we could sit down with the chicago skyline in view. As we walked down the midway, hand in hand, I started to panic a little because there were a ton of people there walking around. I didn’t know what the plan was yet, and started to worry about making it “right”.
As we got to the end of the midway, I saw an underpass through the convention center that takes you on the north or west side of the pier away from the people. When we came out from under the convention center, my fears quickly subsided as I saw about three people, all walking the other direction. I asked her if we could sit down on a bench and just enjoy the moment, and of course she gladly accepted this request.

- Where i proposed
I looked out over the calm water, looked to my left and saw this view (on the left)…I took a very deep breath and said “I really need to talk to you about something”…I knew this completely threw her off guard, but I could see her wheels turning of all the horrible things that I was about to say. Usually I don’t hold my feelings in, and can very aptly tell something what’s going on in my head and heart. I’m sure my beginning of this conversation didn’t bode well for her. I told her how much I hated being in the hospital that day and when the registration person asked what her relationship status was, due to the options, her response was “single”. I told her that I wanted to change that status. I took out a small velvet bag, as Cindy looked at me very confused, and took a deep breath. I fidgeted to get the ring out as Cindy’s “light” came on, and she figured out what I was doing and said “WHAT ARE YOU DOING!?”. I got down on one knee and said…”will you marry me?”.
She began crying and asked me again “what are you doing?”, and said “Of course I will, but WHAT ARE YOU DOING?!!” At this point I began that ever popular process of worrying about whether or not she would like the ring, and put it on her finger. I asked her if she liked it, and she said “I can’t really sit it through my tears”. We sat there for another half hour or so and talked about all of her family and friends who knew what was going to happen this weekend and how I planned the whole thing without her knowing. She cried some more, I smiled some more, we hugged alot and talked about how she didn’t expect this. That plan literally worked to perfection, but that wasn’t all…
I told her I was finally hungry enough to eat now, and could we grab some dinner. We walked (floated) back down the midway to a nice restaurant with outdoor seating and put our name in at the front desk. The young girl working said “It will be about 30 minutes”, and I said “what if we just got engaged” and she looked at Cindy’s ring and smile and said “give me a minute”…she came back and got us and put us at a table right on the patio.

Now, I had heard that Navy Pier does fireworks during the summer, but I wasn’t sure what time, day, or place. I didn’t plan this at all, but from our vantage point, the fireworks were literally straight ahead from where we were sitting. We didn’t have to move an inch. It was a fitting end to an amazing 48 hours, and we didn’t have to say much.
There is no great way to end this blog, because it’s another chapter to this story. Stay tuned.
I know Cindy is also going to blog from her perspective soon…